Current:Home > Contact-usDisputed verdict draws both sides back to court in New Hampshire youth detention center abuse case-InfoLens
Disputed verdict draws both sides back to court in New Hampshire youth detention center abuse case
View Date:2024-12-23 16:34:41
Brentwood, N.H. (AP) — Both sides in a landmark trial over abuse at New Hampshire’s youth detention center returned to the courtroom Monday, seven weeks after jurors delivered what remains an unsettled verdict.
A jury awarded $38 million to David Meehan in May but found the state liable for only one “incident” of abuse at the Youth Development Center in Manchester. Jurors weren’t told that state law caps claims against the state at $475,000 per “incident,” and some later said they wrote “one” on the verdict form to reflect a single case of post-traumatic stress disorder resulting from more than 100 episodes of physical, sexual and emotional abuse.
Meehan’s lawyers have asked Judge Andrew Schulman to set aside just the portion of the verdict where jurors wrote one incident, allowing the $38 million to stand, or to order a new trial focused only on determining the number of incidents. The state, meanwhile, has asked him to impose the cap. Schulman has yet to rule on those motions, and at a hearing Monday, attorneys said more paperwork is coming.
In a May 24 order, Schulman said imposing the cap would be an “unconscionable miscarriage of justice.” He didn’t go that far Monday, but said there was a disconnect between the award and the finding of one incident.
“We don’t know exactly what the jury was thinking,” he said. “But $38 million doesn’t square with a single incident.”
Although they didn’t argue as such at trial, lawyers for the state said jurors appeared to have defined incident as “a single harmful condition” to which the plaintiff was exposed, and as such, the verdict should stand. David Vicinanzo, one of Meehan’s attorneys, characterized that position as “The state is essentially saying, yeah, 100 rapes, 200 rapes, it all equals one rape.”
“What reasonable person thinks that?” he said.
Meehan, 42, went to police in 2017 to report the abuse and sued the state three years later. Since then, 11 former state workers have been arrested although charges against one of them were dropped after the man, now in his early 80s, was found incompetent to stand trial.
Over the four-week trial, Meehan’s attorneys argued that the state encouraged a culture of abuse marked by pervasive brutality, corruption and a code of silence. The state, which portrayed Meehan as a violent child, troublemaking teenager and delusional adult, argued that he waited too long to sue and that it shouldn’t be held liable for the actions of “rogue” employees.
Schulman already rejected what he called the two worst options: reconvening the jury or questioning them about their decision. Other options would be ordering a new trial or adjusting the number of incidents on the verdict form. That latter would be something akin to a process by which a judge can add damages to an original amount awarded by the jury if a defendant waives a new trial. While Monday’s discussion included possible outcomes such as appeals to the state Supreme Court, Schulman said he was trying not to focus on such speculation.
“My job is to rule on the motions in front of me and not necessarily to figure out everybody’s subsequent moves on the chess board,” he said.
veryGood! (38)
Related
- Harriet Tubman posthumously honored as general in Veterans Day ceremony: 'Long overdue'
- Meet the flower-loving, glitter-wearing, ukulele-playing USA skater fighting for medal
- Horoscopes Today, August 6, 2024
- USA men's volleyball stays unbeaten with quarterfinal win over Brazil
- 'The Penguin' spoilers! Colin Farrell spills on that 'dark' finale episode
- Billy Ray Cyrus Settles Divorce From Firerose After Alleged Crazy Insane Scam
- Watch as walking catfish washes up in Florida driveway as Hurricane Debby approached
- Chiefs make Harrison Butker NFL's highest-paid kicker with contract extension, per reports
- After Baltimore mass shooting, neighborhood goes full year with no homicides
- The 2024 MTV VMA Nominations Are Finally Here: See the Complete List
Ranking
- Are banks, post offices, UPS and FedEx open on Veterans Day? Here's what to know
- American discus thrower Valarie Allman makes it back to back gold medals at Paris Games
- Elon Musk sues OpenAI, renewing claims ChatGPT-maker put profits before ‘the benefit of humanity’
- Chicago White Sox lose to Oakland A's for AL record-tying 21st straight defeat
- GM recalling big pickups and SUVs because the rear wheels can lock up, increasing risk of a crash
- Heatstroke death of Baltimore worker during trash collection prompts calls for workplace safety
- Pitbull Stadium is the new home of FIU football. The artist has bought the naming rights
- Chappell Roan may have made history at Lollapalooza with 'biggest set of all time'
Recommendation
-
Stressing over Election Day? Try these apps and tools to calm your nerves
-
Flavor Flav and the lost art of the hype man: Where are hip-hop's supporting actors?
-
Google illegally maintains monopoly over internet search, judge rules
-
Families whose loved ones were left rotting in funeral home owed $950 million, judge rules
-
NYC bans unusual practice of forcing tenants to pay real estate brokers hired by landlords
-
Ferguson thrust them into activism. Now, Cori Bush and Wesley Bell battle for a congressional seat
-
Body believed to be Glacier National Park drowning victim recovered from Avalanche Creek
-
A Virginia man is charged with online threats against Vice President Kamala Harris